Skip to content
Search
Home
Shop by Category
See All Products
News
Instagram
Facebook
Account
Site navigation
Search
Search
Cart
Menu
Site navigation
Home
Shop by Category
See All Products
News
Instagram
Facebook
Account
Item added to cart.
View cart and check out
.
Close
Close
The Coney Island Gift Store ships packages every Tuesday
Close
Buttons
Mermaid Parade, Burlesque at the Beach, The Mermaid Parade, Freak Show, The Coney Island Museum
Filter by
All
42
Beard and Moustache Competition
Brooklyn
Button
coney island
Coney Island Museum
Coney Island USA
Freak Show
Funny Face
Merfolk
Mermaid Parade
Mermaids
Mermen
Motorcycle
parade
Parade 2019
PIN
Sideshows by the Seashore
The Coney Island Film Festival
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Button - 2026 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2025 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - CIUSA Rainbow
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2024 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2023 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2013 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2022 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Sideshow Cast - La Reine the Thrill - Button
Regular price
$2
View
Button - Museum
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2019 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2017 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2016 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2015 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$2
View
Button - CIUSA Logo
SOLD OUT!
View
Button - Tattoo
Regular price
$2
View
Button - Freak Show
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2005 Merm-Aid
Regular price
$2
View
Button - 2004 Merm-Aid
Regular price
$2
View
