Skip to content
Search
Home
Shop by Category
See All Products
News
Instagram
Facebook
Account
Site navigation
Search
Search
Cart
Menu
Site navigation
Home
Shop by Category
See All Products
News
Instagram
Facebook
Account
Item added to cart.
View cart and check out
.
Close
Close
The Coney Island Gift Store ships packages every Tuesday
Close
Products
Filter by
All
38
42
Alive on the Inside
Art
Baby
Bag
Beach
Beach Blanket
Beard and Moustache Competition
Bindlestiff Cavalcade of Youth
BOOK
Brooklyn
Brooklyn Artist
Burlesque
Button
Cat
Circus
coney island
Coney Island Museum
Coney Island USA
Coney Island USA Logo
Congress
Consignment
creepy
Curio
custom
Discounts
Earring
Enamel Pin
film festival
Fine Arts
Freak Show
Funny Face
GIFT
Glassware
GRAFITTI
Halloween
Hand Made
Handmade
Hoodie
Housewares
Jewelry
Key Chain
Kid Friendly
KIDS
LImited Edition
Magic
Magnet
Magnets
Marie Roberts
Marx Brothers
Membership
Merfolk
Mermaid Parade
Mermaids
Mermen
Metal Marvel
mirror
Motorcycle
Mug
mystery
Other Clothes
painting
parade
Parade 2019
PATCH
Photograph
Pillow
PIN
Pint Glass
Post Cards
POSTER
Posters
Publications
Purses/Totes/Bags
Shot Glass
Sideshow
Sideshows by the Seashore
Spring Gala
Squidling Brothers
Sticker
T-Shirt
Tank Top
tchotchke
Tchotchkes
Tees Men
Tees Women
TEST
The Coney Island Film Festival
Tiki
Towel
Toys
Transit
Unisex
Variety Show
Vendor Table
vintage
Wallet
Women
Zombie
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Sticker - Aurora North Miss Coney Island
Regular price
$2
View
Sticker - CIUSA Logo
Regular price
$2
View
Sticker - Dylan Goldberger
Regular price
$12
View
Sticker - Freak Show Square
Regular price
$2
View
Sticker - Hotdog Mermaid
Regular price
$2
View
Sticker - Joker
Regular price
$5
View
Sticker - Museum Square
Regular price
$2
View
Sticker - No Casino
Regular price
$2
View
Sticker - Pink Vlvt Wtch
Regular price
$5
View
Sticker - Sideshow Cat
Regular price
$2
View
Storytelling by the Seashore - November 22, 2025 - 3:00pm
Regular price
$10
View
T-Shirt - 2010 Mermaid Parade
Regular price
$25
View
T-Shirt - 2012 Mermaid Parade - Unisex
Regular price
$25
View
T-Shirt - 2012 Mermaid Parade - White Women
SOLD OUT!
View
T-Shirt - 2015 Mermaid Parade - Women
Regular price
$20
View
T-Shirt - 2018 Mermaid Parade - Black Unisex
Regular price
$25
View
T-Shirt - 2018 Mermaid Parade - Men White
Regular price
$25
View
T-Shirt - 2019 Mermaid Parade - Men
Regular price
$25
View
T-Shirt - 2019 Mermaid Parade - Women
Regular price
$25
View
T-Shirt - 2020 Mermaid Parade - Unisex
From $25
View
←
1
…
14
15
16
17
18
19
→
